Skip to main content

Table 6 Summary of 24-HDR and their characteristics

From: A systematic review of methods to assess intake of saturated fat (SF) among healthy European adults and children: a DEDIPAC (Determinants of Diet and Physical Activity) study

 

Population

Purpose

Method of admin

Structure

Prompts

Portion size

Adults

 EPIC [25, 73]

Adults

30–70 years

Provide comparable food consumption data between several European countries

Computerised, face-to-face interview

1. ‘Quick list’ Chronological entry of all foods and recipes consumed during day

2. Foods are entered per meal

3. Each ‘quick list’ item is described and quantified

Yes

Program mediated

Checklist of foods which are easily forgotten is displayed on screen

Estimated

6 quantification methods including photos (2–6 portion sizes), shapes, household

measurements, standard units, standard portions, volume method. If the portion size estimation methods is unknown this can be entered by the interviewer

 Van Diepen et al. [54]

Adults/Students

Age range not reported

Examine relationship between Mediterranean diet and obesity

Not reported

Not reported

Not reported

Not reported

Adolescents

 HELENA [58, 67, 80]

Adolescents

13–17 years

Assess food and nutrient intake

Computerised, self-administered

Divided into 6 meal occasions. For each occasion the user selects all food and beverages consumed from a standardised food list. Foods and beverages which are not included in the list can be added

Yes

Program mediated

When appropriate, a text box appears on the screen probing for food items which are often eaten in combination with other items (for example, chips, ‘Don’t forget mayonnaise/ ketchup etc.!’) When extreme amounts are entered; a warning is given i.e. zero values are not accepted.

At the end of the 24-h recall, the program checks entries for occurrence of fruit, vegetables and sweets. If one of these items has not been entered, the adolescent is asked whether it really was not consumed

Estimated

Information on quantities was gathered by using household measurements or pictures of portion sizes

Children

 EYHS [60]

Children

9 years

15 years

Examine

personal, environmental, and lifestyle influences on cardiovascular risk factors

Face-to-face interview

A qualitative 1-day record completed at home with help from parents if needed

A face-to-face interactive 24-HDR interview was performed on the following day

Differences between the interview data and the record data were discussed with the participant

Estimated

Portion size was estimated using pictures of portion sizes

 IDEFICS SACINA [61]

Children

2–9 years (parents or guardians as proxies)

Determine the aetiology of overweight, obesity and related disorders

Computerised, face-to-face interview

Hungary: self-admin. 24-HDR at home

6 meal occasions

Yes

Program mediated

Estimated

Photos

  1. SACINA Self-Administered Children and Infants Nutrition Assessment, EPIC European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition, HELENA Healthy Lifestyle in Europe by Nutrition in Adolescence, EYHS European Youth Heart Study, IDEFICS Identification and prevention of Dietary- and lifestyle-induced health EFfects In Children and infantS