Dietary diversity and related factors among lactating women visiting public health facilities in Aksum town, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia

Abstract

Background

Dietary diversity is a proxy indicator of maternal nutrient adequacy. However, little is documented on dietary diversity among lactating mothers. Therefore, this study assessed diet diversity and associated factors among lactating mothers visiting public health facilities in Aksum town, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia.

Methods

An institution based cross-sectional study was conducted on 346 randomly selected lactating women visiting public health facilities of Aksum town in June 2015. Dietary diversity was assessed using 24 h dietary recall method. A mean dietary diversity score (DDS) was computed of nine food groups. Food insecurity access was measured using 9 items Household Food Insecurity Access Scale (HFIAS). Data were entered and analyzed using SPSS version 20.

Results

More than a quarter (27.2 %) of the lactating mothers was from food insecure households. The mean DDS was 3.4 and a total of 56.4 % lactating mothers had low dietary diversity (less than mean DDS). Average monthly income, home gardening and source of drinking water were associated with low dietary diversity. Lactating mothers who had monthly income of less than 501 ETB [AOR = 2.3, 95 % CI (1.2, 4.6)] and 501 to 1500 ETB [AOR = 3.0, 95 % CI (1.4, 6.3)] were more likely to have low dietary diversity than those who had monthly income above 1500 ETB. And those who did not practice home gardening were more likely to have low dietary diversity than their counterparts [AOR = 2.1, 95 % CI (1.01, 4.2)]. Regarding source of drinking water, mothers who reported protected well as a main source were more likely to have low dietary diversity compared to those who reported tap water as main source [AOR = 4.5, 95 % CI (1.1, 18.2)].

Conclusions

Dietary diversity among lactating mothers was low. Factors like monthly income less than 501 ETB and 501 to 1500 ETB, not having home gardening, and source of drinking water from protected well were significantly associated with low dietary diversity. Attention should be paid to dietary diversity of lactating mothers to improve their nutritional status, and that of their children and their family.

Background

Women at reproductive age, particularly those who live in low and middle income countries, are vulnerable to malnutrition for two major reasons. Physiological vulnerability which comes with childbearing is the first reason. Moreover, maternal nutrient needs increase during pregnancy and lactation, and when these needs are not met, women may suffer from malnutrition [1–5]. During lactation, the energy, protein, and other nutrients in breast milk come from a mother’s diet or her own body stores. Lactating women who do not get enough energy and nutrients in their diets risk maternal depletion [3–6]. This exacerbates maternal malnutrition [7, 8]. In addition, maternal deficiencies of nutrients can affect the quality of breast milk which can adversely affect the nutritional status of their child and eventually compromise the overall growth and development of the child [3–5, 9, 10].

According to the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) conceptual framework of malnutrition, the immediate causes of maternal malnutrition are inadequate dietary intake and diseases; while the underlying causes are inadequate access for food, inadequate care for women and insufficient health services and unhealthy environment [11]. These causes are recognized as stemming from wider contextual factors such as educational and socioeconomic status, ethnic and cultural beliefs, agricultural practices, national policies, and food insecurity [12].

One of the proxy indicators for measuring dietary adequacy among lactating mothers is dietary diversity which is defined as the number of different foods or food groups (9 food groups in this case) consumed over a given reference period [13–21]. The diets of lactating mothers reflect not only their own intake, but also the diets of their small children and families [22–25]. That is, maternal dietary diversity is also strongly linked to that of infants in the same household and to the average household nutrient adequacy. In short, lactating mothers with higher dietary diversity have children and family with higher dietary diversity [19, 22–25]. Hence, ensuring maternal dietary diversity to the acceptable level is very important in tackling malnutrition.

However, literatures evidenced that dietary diversity among lactating mothers is very low in Ethiopia. According to a study conducted in three countries; Vietnam, Bangladesh, and Ethiopia, dietary diversity was very low in nearly three fourth of lactating mothers in Ethiopia [26]. A number of factors could contribute to poor dietary diversity. Evidences show that many factors including maternal education, food security and socioeconomic status could act as barriers to diversified dietary use [26, 27]. Moreover, maternal knowledge [26], health status [26, 27] and season could influence dietary diversity [16, 27]. These factors could vary from setting to setting. Therefore, information on dietary diversity and associated factors of lactating mothers are urgently needed for prioritizing, designing and initiating intervention programs aiming at improving maternal and child nutrition. However, little is documented on dietary diversity and the associated factors in the study area. Therefore, this study aims to assess dietary diversity and associated factors among lactating mothers in Aksum town, Tigray region, North Ethiopia.

Methods

Study setting and population

Health facility based cross-sectional design was employed to assess dietary diversity among lactating mothers in public health facilities of Aksum town. Aksum town is located in the Northern part of Ethiopia with an elevation of 2131 m (6991 ft) above sea level, with annual average temperature of 18.3⁰c and annual rain fall of 652 mm. It is 1042 kms far from Addis Ababa, the capital of Ethiopia and 270 kms away from Mekelle (the capital city of Tigray regional state). Aksum is the ancient historical town which has an area of 3247 km². Based on the town administrative office 2013 report, the total population is 59,300 (28,637 are males and 30,663 are females). Administratively, the town is divided in to 4 kebeles (the smallest administrative units). In Aksum town, there are 2 governmental health centers and 1 governmental general hospital. Lactating mothers who visit the public health facilities during the study period were considered as the study population. The inclusion criteria were being 15–49 years lactating mother and being resident of Aksum town for at least 6 months. Lactating mothers who were seriously ill and/or had difficulty to communicate were excluded. The data collection was undertaken in June, 2015.

Sample size and sampling procedures

The required sample size was determined using single-population proportion formula with the following assumptions: 50 % of proportion of lactating mothers who have below mean diet diversity score, 95 % of confidence interval and 5 % marginal error. The final sample size was 384. Respondents who fulfilled the inclusion criteria were selected using systematic random sampling technique. The interview was started by selecting a random start using lottery method. Then every 2^nd lactating woman visiting the public health facilities were interviewed. Eventually, a total of 346 lactating mothers were participated in this study.

Data collection

Data were collected by exit interview using structured and pre-tested questionnaire adapted from different literatures mainly Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) Guidelines for measuring household and individual dietary diversity, 2011 [15] and Household food insecurity access scale (HFIAS) to measure food security [23]. The questionnaire had four main contents: socio-demographic characteristics; source of food, feeding practice and other individual related factors; dietary diversity, and food security related questions. The questionnaire was first prepared in English and then translated to Tigrigna and translated back to English to observe its consistency. Finally, the questionnaire was also pretested on 5 % of the total sample size in Suhul general hospital found in Shire Endaselassie town of North Western zone of Tigray Regional state. Necessary modifications were made on the questionnaire based on the findings of the pretest.

Dietary diversity score (DDS) was collected and calculated as the sum of the number of different food groups consumed by the mother in the 24 h prior to the assessment. A total of nine food groups were considered in this study (i.e. starchy staples, dark green leafy vegetables, other vitamin A rich fruits and vegetables, other fruits and vegetables, fats and oils, meat and fish, eggs, legumes, nuts and seeds and milk and milk products [28]. Finally, respondents with < 3.4 mean food groups consumed were considered as having lower dietary diversity whereas those with ≥3.4 mean food groups consumed were considered as having moderate or high dietary diversity.

Food insecurity access was measured using items from the HFIAS [23, 29–31]. The HFIAS consists of 9 items specific to an experience of food insecurity occurring within the previous 4 weeks. Each respondent indicated whether he/she had encountered the following due to lack of food or money to buy food in the previous 1 month: (1) worried about running out of food, (2) lack of preferred food, (3) the respondent or another adult had limited access to a variety of foods due to a lack of resources (4) forced to eat un preferred food due to lack of resources, (5) eating smaller portions, (6) skipping meals, (7) the household ran out of food, (8) going to sleep hungry, and (9) going 24 h without food. Finally, individuals were classified as food secure if the individuals responded ‘no’ to all of the items and insecure if the individuals responded ‘yes’ to at least one of the 9 items included on the HFIAS tool.

Two public health officers, who were fluent in the local language (Tigrigna), participated in the data collection process. The data collection process was supervised by two senior Public Health professionals and the principal investigators. Both data collectors and supervisors were trained for 1 day about the contents of the questionnaire and on how to collect the data properly in order to minimize errors. The principal investigators and supervisors had made daily supervision during the whole data collection process. The questionnaire was reviewed and checked for completeness, accuracy and consistency by the supervisors and investigators daily and at the end of the whole data collection process.

Operational definition

Diet diversity score

Is the sum of food groups eaten in the previous 24 h, serves as a proxy indicator of nutrient adequacy of an individual’s diet. Low dietary diversity (<3.4 mean food groups consumed) and moderate or high dietary diversity (≥3.4 mean food groups consumed). The diet was classified according to the 9 food groups recommended by the FAO [28].

Food security

Food insecurity access was measured using items from the HFIAS [23, 29–31]. The HFIAS consists of 9 items specific to an experience of food insecurity occurring within the previous 4 weeks. Each respondent indicated whether he/she had encountered the 9 items included in the HFIAS due to lack of food or money to buy food in the previous 1 month. Finally, individuals were classified as food secure if the individuals responded ‘no’ to all of the items and insecure if the individuals responded ‘yes’ to at least one of the 9 items included on the HFIAS tool.

Data analysis

After all the relevant data were collected, the data were coded on pre- arranged coding sheet by the investigators. Dietary intake was converted to 9 food groups to assess dietary diversity of the subjects. Data were entered, cleaned and then analyzed using SPSS version 20. Descriptive summaries using frequencies and proportions were used to present the study results. In this study, the dependent variable was dietary diversity coded 1 as lower dietary diversity and 0 as moderate or high dietary diversity. In the bivariate analysis, the independent variables with a P-value less than 0.2 with the dependent variable were fitted in to a multivariate logistic regression model to identify their independent effect on dietary diversity. Independent variables included in the multivariate analysis include educational status, occupation, residential address, monthly income, source of drinking water, availability of latrine, home gardening, history of illness, duration of menstruation (in days) and daily eating pattern in the previous 7 days. The association between the dependent and the independent variables was measured using odds ratio (OR) with 95 % Confidence Interval (C.I). Those variables with p-value of less than 0.05 in the multivariate analysis were considered as significant.

Results

Characteristics of respondents

Table 1 shows characteristics of respondents. Three hundred forty six lactating women were included in this study yielding a response rate of 90.1 %. The non- response rate was basically due to refusal to participate in the study and the lesser flow of mothers especially from rural areas to the health facilities because of increased summer activities by the farmers. More than two-thirds of the respondents (69.4 %) were in the age group of 15–30 years and the mean age of the respondents was 29.8 (±6.1) years. Sixty six (19.1 %) of the respondents were rural dwellers. The majority of the respondents were Orthodox Christian (88.4 %) whilst the others were Muslims. Two hundred ninety nine (95.7 %) of the lactating mothers were married and 299 (86 %) were Tigray. Almost half of the women (46.0 %) attended at least high school. Fifty seven (16.5 %) of the lactating mothers in this study had no formal education. One hundred sixty two (46.8 %) of lactating women were house wives. Regarding the family size of the lactating mothers participated in the study, 321 (92.8 %) of them reported that their family size was four and above. Concerning the source of drinking water for members of household, 276 (79.8 %) mothers reported tap water as their source of drinking water. Sixty two (17.9 %) reported that they had no toilet facility in their home. More than half (56.6 %) of the lactating mothers had monthly income of less than 501 ETB. Among the total lactating mothers included in this study, 53 (15.3 %) reported history of illness in the previous 2 weeks. Most of the respondents (78.0 %) reported that their usual duration of menstruation was 4–6 days.

Table 1 Characteristics of lactating mothers (n = 346) visiting public health facilities in Aksum, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia, June 2015

Source of food and feeding practices

Table 2 depicts source of food and feeding practices of the respondents. About two-thirds of lactating women (60.7 %) reported less than three meals per day during the previous 7 days. Only 11.8 % reported having a garden at home. Pertaining to the main source of food for the household members, 143 (42.3 %) mothers reported that their main source of food was household’s own production. Regarding the frequency of fruit and vegetables consumption in previous 24 h, more than half (59.2 %) and 183 (52.9 %) lactating mothers reported that they did not consume fruits and vegetables respectively. Among the lactating mothers, 55 (15.9 %) reported alcohol consumption during the previous 7 days.

Table 2 Source of food and feeding practice among lactating mothers (n = 346) visiting public health facilities in Aksum, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia, June 2015

Dietary diversity characteristics

Table 3 shows dietary diversity characteristics of the lactating mothers. The mean dietary diversity score among the lactating mothers was 3.4. Among the total lactating mothers, 56.4 % (95 % CI: 50.6, 61.6) had low dietary diversity (dietary diversity score less than 3.4) and 43.6 % (95 % CI: 38.4, 49.4) of them had moderate or high dietary diversity (dietary diversity score greater or equal to 3.4) in the previous 24 h. Regarding the food groups consumed by the lactating mothers in the previous 24 h, nearly all women (99.4 %) consumed starchy staples and more than two-thirds (69.1 %) consumed legumes, nuts and seeds.

Table 3 Dietary diversity frequency of lactating mothers (n = 346) visiting public health facilities in Aksum, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia, June 2015

Food security characteristics

Table 4 indicates food security characteristics of the lactating mothers. From the nine HFIAS items; lack of preferred food (12.1 %), worried about running out of food (11.8 %) and the respondent or another adult had limited access to a variety of foods due to a lack of resources (11 %) were the most frequently reported concerns about food insecurity. Overall, more than one fourth (27.2 %) of the lactating mothers were food insecure.

Table 4 HFIAS items of lactating mothers (n = 346) visiting public health facilities in Aksum, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia, June 2015

Factors associated with dietary diversity

Table 5 shows bivariate and multivariate analysis of factors associated with dietary diversity of lactating mothers. In the bivariate level analysis, elementary education, being unemployed, monthly income of less than 501 ETB and between 501 ETB and 1500 ETB, having two meals a day during previous 7 days, and having protected well source of drinking water were associated with low dietary diversity. In the multivariable level analysis; monthly income of less than 501 and 501 to 1500 ETB, not practicing home gardening, and protected well as main source of drinking water were predictors of low dietary diversity.

Table 5 Bivariate and multivariate associations of factors with dietary diversity among lactating mothers visiting public health facilities in Aksum, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia, June 2015

Lactating mothers who had monthly income less than 501 ETB and 501 to 1500 ETB were 2.3 and 3.0 times more likely to have low dietary diversity than those who had monthly income above 1500 ETB respectively [[AOR = 2.3, 95 % CI (1.2–4.6)] and [AOR = 3.0, 95 % CI (1.4–6.3)] respectively]. Among the lactating mothers, those who did not practice home gardening were 2.1 times more likely to have low dietary diversity than those who practice home gardening [AOR = 2.1, 95 % CI (1.01, 4.2)]. Regarding source of drinking water, lactating mothers who reported protected well as a main source were 4.5 times more likely to have low dietary diversity than those who reported tap water as main source [AOR = 4.5, 95 % CI (1.1, 18.2)].

Discussion

The study has assessed the dietary diversity among lactating mothers visiting public health facilities in Aksum town, Tigray region, Ethiopia. The mean DDS among the lactating women was 3.4 and 56 % (95 % CI: 50.6, 61.6) of the women had DDS < 3.4. This finding is lower than the finding of study conducted in three countries; Vietnam, Bangladesh, and Ethiopia, by Nguyen et al [26], in which dietary diversity was low in nearly three fourths of lactating mothers in Ethiopia. This might be explained by the difference in study period which can results in food security status change. In the previous study, more than two thirds of the study participants were food insecure. While in the present study, nearly a quarter was food insecure. There is also similar difference in educational status between study participants of both studies which could be another explanation for the observed discrepancy. Conversely, the finding of the present study is far higher than the prevalence of low dietary diversity among lactating mothers in the study from Vietnam, Bangladesh and Ethiopia [26]. This might be due to the difference in education, feeding culture and food security.

In this study, around 99.4 and 69.1 % of the lactating mothers had consumed starchy staples, and legumes, nuts and seeds respectively in the previous 24 h. Conversely, milk and milk products food group, and meat and fish food group were least consumed groups (12.4 and 17.1 % respectively). This finding is almost consistent with the finding of other similar study conducted in Vietnam, Bangladesh and Ethiopia by Nguyen et al [26] and in Kenya by Ongosi et al [36].

Lactating mothers visiting public health facilities with a monthly income of 501–1500 ETB and <501 ETB were 3 and 2.3 times more likely to have low dietary diversity respectively, when compared to mothers who earned >1500 ETB per month. This study is in agreement with the study conducted in Bangladesh by Thorne-Lyman et al [32]. It has demonstrated that dietary diversity was significantly associated with the wealth status of the study participants; as the wealth index increased the likelihood of consuming diversified food have been observed to increase. A study in low and middle income countries also indicated that higher socio-economic status was associated with higher diet diversity score [33]. This could be due to the fact that low income earners recognized to be negatively affected on their preference of quality and quantity of diversified food groups consumed in their feeding arrangements attributable to income.

Home gardening practice of the study participants was found to be predictor of dietary diversity in this study. Lactating mothers who did not practice home gardening showed more than two folds higher likelihood of consuming low diversified diets when compared to mothers who practice home gardening. This study agreed with studies conducted in Philippines by Cabalda et al [34] and in Ethiopia by Tesema et al [35]. These studies have demonstrated that home gardening was strongly associated with diet diversity and with frequency of vegetable consumption. This might be due to the reason that households with gardens were beneficiary from gardens they own as a means to diversifying their daily food. It was also indicated that parents with home gardening would grow vegetables and get additional diet options that enhance the diversity of the household’s food sources [35].

Furthermore, source of drinking water was found to be a determinant predictor of dietary diversity. Lactating mothers who reported protected well as a main source of drinking water were more likely to have low dietary diversity than those who reported tap water as main source. This might be partly explained by the difference in socioeconomic status as shown in a study conducted in three countries; Vietnam, Bangladesh, and Ethiopia, by Nguyen et al [26], in which household socioeconomic status (SES) was found to be positively associated with maternal dietary diversity.

Nevertheless of its marginality in the multivariate model, occupation of the study subjects has been associated with dietary diversity in the current study; lactating mothers who were unemployed during the study period had two folds higher likelihood of consuming poorly diversified food items when compared to those who owned private business. The possible explanation for this could be the purchasing power of lactating mothers is dictated by the presence and absence of occupation that they rely on as a source of income.

Even if the proportion of food insecurity among the lactating mothers in this study was 27.2 %, it did not associate with dietary diversity. A study done in rural Cambodia and a study done in Rural Populations of Kilosa District, Tanzania indicated that there is no association between food security and dietary diversity [36, 37]. However, a study done in older Taiwanese has indicated that there is significant association between food security and dietary diversity [38]. The difference in association of food security and dietary diversity among the study populations may be related with difference in educational level and socio economic status.

This study has some limitations. Although efforts were made to ensure representativeness of eligible women in the study area, no attempt was made to address seasonal variation which can affect food availability that can in turn influence dietary intake and diversity. Moreover, there is difficulty to measure food compositions and dishes due to diverse cultures and different ways of traditional food preparations. For example, injera (local name) is a food mostly consumed by the study participants. Injera can be prepared by composing different cereals which is differently composed in each household based on their economic ability to buy the different cereals.

Conclusions

The previous 24 h recall dietary diversity assessment indicated that mean DDS among the lactating mothers was 3.4. Among the lactating mothers, 56.4 % had DDS less than 3.4. Factors like average monthly income less than 501 ETB and from 501 to 1500 ETB, not practicing home gardening, and protected well as main source of drinking water were strongly associated with low dietary diversity. Hence, additional programs and interventions should be designed and implemented conjointly with other health care services delivered in health facilities to address low dietary diversity among lactating mothers. Apart from this, nutritional education is essential in order to aware mothers on the importance of diversified diet consumption.

Abbreviations

AOR, adjusted odds ratio; CEO, Chief Executive Officer; CI, confidence interval; COR, crude odds ratio; DDS, Dietary Diversity Score; ETB, Ethiopian birr; FAO, Food and Agriculture Organization; HFIAS, Household Food Insecurity Access Scale; IRB, Institutional Review Board; OR, odds ratio; SES, socioeconomic status; UNICEF, United Nations Children’s Fund